
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge
Best for waterfront Brooklyn views, easy access to Brooklyn Bridge Park and DUMBO, and a nature-focused stay with a seasonal rooftop pool.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is a five-star, nature-forward waterfront hotel in Brooklyn Heights with rooftop swimming, locally sourced dining, and a large spa — good for travelers who want a quieter, park-side base with skyline views. Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York is a crystal-themed Midtown luxury hotel with a full-service spa and an indoor pool — read this if you want classic Midtown glam, MoMA/ Rockefeller Center proximity, and a refined restaurant bar scene.
Updated · about 5.6 km apart

Best for waterfront Brooklyn views, easy access to Brooklyn Bridge Park and DUMBO, and a nature-focused stay with a seasonal rooftop pool.

Best for proximity to Midtown attractions (MoMA, Rockefeller Center) and a classic luxury experience with an indoor pool and a signature French restaurant.
When 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge wins: choose 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge if you want waterfront access to Brooklyn Bridge Park, outdoor rooftop pool time (seasonal), locally sourced dining, and a quieter Brooklyn-base with easy ferry/subway links into Manhattan.
When Baccarat wins: choose Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York if you prefer to be in Midtown within walking distance of MoMA and Rockefeller Center, want an indoor pool and a full-service spa, and value a glamorous Midtown hotel experience.
Bottom line: both are five-star choices but serve different priorities — 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for park-side, nature-minded Brooklyn stays with rooftop pool access; Baccarat for central Midtown location and traditional hotel luxury with indoor leisure facilities.
| Category | 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge | Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Nature-forward, design-led waterfront hotel with Brooklyn park views and sustainable touches. | Glamorous, crystal-themed Midtown luxury hotel with refined French-influenced dining and polished service. |
| Location | Pier 1, Brooklyn Bridge Park — Brooklyn Heights waterfront (steps to DUMBO and ferries). | 28 West 53rd Street, Midtown Manhattan — steps from MoMA and Rockefeller Center. |
| Size (rooms) | 194–195 guest rooms and suites. | 114 guestrooms. |
| Adult/minimum age policy | Guest booking and check-in must be 18+; property is all-ages but some pool areas have 21+ sections. | Not adults-only; general property is open to all ages (minimum age to check in noted as 21 in supplier listing). |
| Pools | Heated seasonal rooftop outdoor pool (open daily 7am–7pm, weather permitting); Sky Swim Lounge has 21+ area. | Indoor pool available on-site. |
| Restaurants & bars | Barbuto Brooklyn (California-Italian), Neighbors Café (grab-and-go), Harriet's Rooftop & Harriet's Lounge (cocktails, skyline views). | Grand Salon (French cuisine) plus a bar/lounge; room service available (limited hours). |
| Spa & wellness | Bamford Wellness Spa (5,000 sq ft, nine treatment rooms, HigherDOSE tools) and 24-hour Field House fitness center with Peloton bikes. | Full-service spa with treatments and an indoor pool, sauna and steam-room facilities listed. |
| Known for | Waterfront setting and park access; sustainability and nature-led design. | Midtown location near MoMA and Rockefeller Center and crystal-inspired design/brand cachet. |
| Accessibility & services | 24-hour front desk, concierge, valet parking (fee), daily housekeeping, complimentary high-speed Wi‑Fi. | |
| Event spaces | Multiple event venues including Meadow Rue ballroom and rooftop/terrace venues; several flexible meeting rooms. | Number of meeting rooms listed as 1 in supplier listing; event-space specifics not listed in the supplier facts here. |
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge sits on Pier 1 at Brooklyn Bridge Park with direct park access and skyline views of Lower Manhattan.
Choose 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for park-side waterfront access and a quieter Brooklyn base with skyline views.
Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York is in Midtown, a short walk from MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
Choose Baccarat for immediate Midtown access to museums, shopping, and theater.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge has roughly 194–195 rooms and suites with nature-focused materials and skyline or park views.
Pick 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge if you want larger property variety and rooms focused on natural materials and views of Brooklyn/Manhattan.
Baccarat lists 114 guestrooms with room names such as ATELIER KING BED, Classic King, Grand Classic rooms and several suites.
Choose Baccarat for a smaller, boutique-feeling Midtown property with crystal-luxe presentation and suite options.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge focuses on locally sourced, seasonal food across multiple venues that include a signature restaurant and rooftop bar.
If you want locally sourced menus and rooftop cocktails with Manhattan skyline views, 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is the better fit.
Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York offers refined dining centered on Grand Salon with French-influenced cuisine and a bar.
Choose Baccarat for a classic, restaurant-centric Midtown dining experience in a luxury setting.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge’s signature leisure draw is its heated seasonal rooftop pool with skyline and bridge views.
If an outdoor rooftop swim with Manhattan skyline and park views is a priority, choose 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge in warmer months.
Baccarat provides an indoor pool as part of its on-site recreational amenities, suitable year-round.
Pick Baccarat if you prefer an indoor pool that’s available year-round and integrated with a full-service spa.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge pairs Bamford Wellness Spa services with a 24-hour fitness center and active rooftop nightlife on select evenings.
If you want a strong spa program plus rooftop nightlife and round-the-clock fitness, 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge covers all three.
Baccarat’s wellness offerings include a full-service spa and accompanying fitness/recreation options, alongside a quieter, classic hotel nightlife offering.
Baccarat is a better match if you favor indoor spa and relaxation facilities with refined evening dining and bar service.

1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge — immediate access to Brooklyn Bridge Park, DUMBO and an outdoor rooftop pool with skyline views.

Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York — steps from MoMA, Rockefeller Center and Fifth Avenue shopping.

1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge — heated seasonal rooftop pool open to registered guests with skyline and bridge views.

Baccarat Hotel and Residences New York — indoor pool plus full-service spa and sauna options available year-round.
Baccarat is the better choice for Midtown sightseeing — it’s a short walk to MoMA, Rockefeller Center and Fifth Avenue shopping.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge has a heated seasonal rooftop outdoor pool (guest-only access, weather permitting). Baccarat has an indoor pool.
Yes. 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge features Bamford Wellness Spa with nine treatment rooms; Baccarat lists a full-service spa with reservations required.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is explicitly pet-friendly and offers amenities for pets; Baccarat’s supplier listing notes a pet fee policy (USD 250 per stay) and does not list a no-pets policy.
Explore how 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·