
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge
Best for skyline views, outdoor rooftop swimming, and a wellness-led Brooklyn stay.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is a waterfront, nature-forward 5-star hotel in Brooklyn Heights with a seasonal rooftop pool, wellness spa, and locally sourced dining; read this if you want a Brooklyn-base with skyline views and outdoor space. Four Seasons Hotel New York is a high-profile Midtown 5-star luxury hotel near Central Park and Fifth Avenue; read this if you prefer a classic, centrally located Manhattan luxury stay.
Updated

Best for skyline views, outdoor rooftop swimming, and a wellness-led Brooklyn stay.

Best for a traditional Midtown luxury address near Fifth Avenue and Central Park with large event facilities.
When 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge wins: choose 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for waterfront Brooklyn Bridge Park access, a seasonal heated rooftop pool (guest-only), stronger emphasis on sustainability and a sizable onsite Bamford Wellness Spa—good for travelers who want outdoor views and a neighborhood feel outside of Midtown.
When Four Seasons Hotel New York wins: choose the Four Seasons for a classic Midtown address within a short walk of Fifth Avenue and Central Park, extensive meeting/ballroom space, and the reassurance of a large, internationally known luxury brand—good for business travelers and visitors focused on Midtown attractions.
The bottom line: pick 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge if you want waterfront Brooklyn, rooftop pool time, and wellness programming; pick Four Seasons Hotel New York if you need a central Manhattan location and a high-profile Midtown luxury experience.
| Category | 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge | Four Seasons Hotel New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Nature-led, design-forward waterfront luxury | Classic Midtown five-star luxury, formal service |
| Location | Brooklyn Heights, directly adjacent to Brooklyn Bridge Park and Pier 1 | Midtown Manhattan near 5th Avenue and Central Park |
| Size (rooms) | 194–195 rooms and suites | 368 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Check-in / Check-out | Check-in 4:00 PM · Check-out 12:00 PM | Check-in 3:00 PM · Check-out 12:00 PM |
| Pools / signature outdoor amenity | Heated seasonal rooftop pool (open daily 7am–7pm when weather permits) reserved for registered guests | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Barbuto Brooklyn, Neighbors Café, Harriet’s Rooftop, Harriet’s Lounge, in‑room dining | The Garden Restaurant, bar/lounge, 24-hour room service |
| Spa & fitness | Bamford Wellness Spa (9 treatment rooms) and The Field House 24-hour fitness center with Peloton bikes | 24-hour fitness facilities; spa details not published in supplier listing |
| Known for | Waterfront views, sustainability, wellness programming, rooftop pool | Central Midtown address, proximity to Fifth Avenue and Central Park, large meeting/ballroom space |
| Event & meeting space | Multiple venues including Meadow Rue ballroom (5,545 sq ft) and flexible meeting rooms; capacity up to ~1,000 in combined spaces | Conference center and meeting rooms totalling 12,120 sq ft (1,126 m²) with ballroom and reception spaces |
| Pet policy | Pet-friendly (no refundable pet deposit; pet beds and bowls) | Guests can arrange to bring pets by contacting the property directly (supplier notes) |
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge sits at Pier 1 in Brooklyn Bridge Park with close access to DUMBO, the Brooklyn Bridge, ferries and promenade views of Lower Manhattan.
Choose this hotel for a waterfront Brooklyn base and easy outdoor access to parks and ferries.
Four Seasons Hotel New York sits in Midtown Manhattan steps from Fifth Avenue and a short walk to Central Park and many Midtown attractions.
Choose Four Seasons for a central Manhattan location close to major Midtown sights and shopping.
Rooms at 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge emphasize nature-forward design, local materials and skyline or harbor views.
If you want design-focused rooms with Brooklyn or skyline sights and sustainability credentials, this is the pick.
Four Seasons offers individually decorated guestrooms with premium bedding and amenities oriented toward classic luxury.
Pick Four Seasons for larger inventory of traditionally styled luxury rooms in Midtown, including Central Park–view suite options.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge focuses on local purveyors, a chef-driven signature restaurant and rooftop nightlife.
Choose 1 Hotel for neighborhood-driven menus, rooftop cocktails and a relaxed Brooklyn dining scene.
Four Seasons Hotel New York lists on-site dining including The Garden Restaurant and a bar/lounge with 24-hour room service.
Choose Four Seasons for a classic Manhattan hotel dining setup and round-the-clock room service.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge’s seasonal heated rooftop pool is a major draw in warm months.
If rooftop pool access with skyline and East River views matters, 1 Hotel is the clear choice in summer months.
Four Seasons Hotel New York’s supplier listing highlights Midtown location and in‑hotel services but does not publish a pool on the listing.
Four Seasons emphasizes Midtown services and event space; published supplier data does not show a pool.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge centers wellness with a full Bamford Wellness Spa plus a 24-hour fitness center and active programming.
Pick this hotel if spa offerings, 24-hour fitness and rooftop nightlife are priorities.
Four Seasons provides 24-hour fitness facilities and a range of guest services; the supplier listing emphasizes business and meeting support.
Choose Four Seasons for robust business services and a round-the-clock fitness option; check directly with the property for full spa details.

Heated seasonal rooftop pool with East River and Manhattan skyline views, plus an adults-only Sky Swim Lounge area.

Steps from Fifth Avenue and a short walk to Central Park—ideal if you want to be based in Midtown Manhattan.

Bamford Wellness Spa with nine treatment rooms and specialized wellness tools and therapies.

Extensive conference center and meeting rooms with 12,120 sq ft (1,126 m²) of event space listed in the supplier data.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge — it sits at Pier 1 on Brooklyn Bridge Park with direct waterfront access and skyline views.
Four Seasons Hotel New York — it’s located in Midtown a short walk from Fifth Avenue and Central Park according to the supplier listing.
Both list fitness facilities; 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge publishes a full Bamford Wellness Spa and detailed spa hours. Four Seasons lists 24-hour fitness facilities and concierge/business services, but spa details are not published in the provided supplier listing.
Both properties allow guests of all ages; neither is adults-only. (Note: some areas at 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge, like Sky Swim Lounge tables, are 21+.)
Explore how 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·