
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge
Best for skyline photos, Brooklyn Bridge Park access, and a seasonal rooftop pool with views of Lower Manhattan.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is a nature‑forward, waterfront five‑star hotel in Brooklyn Heights with seasonal rooftop swimming and locally sourced dining — good for travelers who want easy access to Brooklyn Bridge Park and skyline views. Mandarin Oriental, New York is a five‑star Columbus Circle hotel with a large spa, indoor pool, and views of Central Park and the skyline — read this if you want a Midtown base near Lincoln Center, MoMA and uptown shopping.
Updated · about 4.0 km apart

Best for skyline photos, Brooklyn Bridge Park access, and a seasonal rooftop pool with views of Lower Manhattan.

Best for a Midtown location, spa-focused stays, and rooms with city or park views next to Columbus Circle.
When 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge wins: Choose 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge if you want a Brooklyn base steps from Brooklyn Bridge Park, a seasonal rooftop pool and locally focused restaurants with skyline-facing bars.
When Mandarin Oriental, New York wins: Choose Mandarin Oriental if you prefer a Midtown location beside Columbus Circle and Central Park, an indoor pool and a larger, full-service spa program in a long-established international brand.
Bottom line: Both are five‑star city hotels but serve different needs — pick 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for a waterfront Brooklyn stay with rooftop swimming and local dining; pick Mandarin Oriental, New York for a Central Park/Columbus Circle base with an expansive spa and year‑round indoor pool.
| Category | 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge | Mandarin Oriental, New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Nature-led design, Brooklyn waterfront, modern and sustainable | Refined Midtown luxury with skyline/park vistas and polished service |
| Location | Pier 1, Brooklyn Bridge Park; minutes to DUMBO and Brooklyn Bridge | 80 Columbus Circle at 60th Street; steps from Columbus Circle and Central Park |
| Size (guest rooms) | 194–195 guest rooms and suites | 244 guestrooms |
| Who can stay | All ages (main guest must be 18+ to check in) | All ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Heated seasonal outdoor rooftop pool (guest-only; weather permitting) | Indoor pool (number of indoor pools: 1) |
| Restaurants & bars | Barbuto Brooklyn, Neighbors Café, Harriet’s Rooftop, Harriet’s Lounge | MO Lounge plus 24‑hour room service; 1 restaurant listed and 2 bars/lounges |
| Spa & wellness | Bamford Wellness Spa (5,000 sq ft, nine treatment rooms) and 24‑hour gym | Full‑service spa with treatment rooms and fitness facilities |
| Known for | Waterfront location, rooftop pool, farm‑to‑table dining and sustainability | Central Park/Columbus Circle location, large spa program and city views |
| Transport links | DUMBO ferry landing and High Street–Brooklyn Bridge subway near hotel | Near Columbus Circle (subway lines, close to Lincoln Center and Midtown) |
| View options | East River, Brooklyn Bridge and Lower Manhattan skyline | Central Park and Midtown skyline views; Hudson River/park view room types listed |
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge sits at Pier 1 on Brooklyn Bridge Park with immediate park and waterfront access.
Pick 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge if you want a waterfront Brooklyn base and quick park access.
Mandarin Oriental, New York is located at Columbus Circle, bordering Central Park and Midtown attractions.
Pick Mandarin Oriental for a Midtown location with immediate access to Central Park and cultural sites.
Rooms at 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge emphasize natural materials, skyline or waterfront perspectives and sustainability.
Rooms suit travelers who want eco-conscious design and close waterfront views of Lower Manhattan.
Mandarin Oriental's rooms offer Central Park, Hudson River or skyline vistas and premium bedding.
Mandarin Oriental is a strong choice for guests prioritizing large windows and city/park views in Midtown.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge focuses on locally sourced menus and several on‑site food and drink venues.
Choose 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for restaurants rooted in Brooklyn produce and rooftop cocktail spots.
Mandarin Oriental lists MO Lounge and 24‑hour room service; the property has one main restaurant and two bars/lounges.
Mandarin Oriental suits guests who want refined in‑house dining and late‑night room service in Midtown.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge’s signature pool is a heated seasonal rooftop pool with skyline and bridge views.
If an outdoor rooftop pool and skyline/bridge views matter, 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is the pick.
Mandarin Oriental provides an indoor pool, available year‑round as part of its wellness offerings.
Choose Mandarin Oriental if you prefer an indoor pool and year‑round swimming access.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge houses the Bamford Wellness Spa and active nightlife options on site.
If you want a spa plus rooftop nightlife and a 24‑hour gym, 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge combines both.
Mandarin Oriental emphasizes its full‑service spa and quieter, refined lounge bars.
Mandarin Oriental is geared to travelers looking for a comprehensive spa program and calm upscale lounges.

Immediate access to Brooklyn Bridge Park, Pier 1 and waterfront promenades.

Steps from Columbus Circle and Central Park with easy access to Midtown cultural sites.

A heated seasonal rooftop pool with direct views of the Brooklyn Bridge and Lower Manhattan skyline.

A large full‑service spa plus an indoor pool make it easier to plan wellness visits any season.
Mandarin Oriental has a year‑round indoor pool; 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge has a heated rooftop pool that’s seasonal and weather dependent.
Mandarin Oriental is at Columbus Circle beside Central Park and is closer to Lincoln Center and Midtown museums.
Both have solid on‑site dining: 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge emphasizes local, farm‑forward options and rooftop bars; Mandarin Oriental offers MO Lounge, 24‑hour room service and two bars/lounges.
No. Both hotels accept guests of all ages (note: 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge requires the main guest to be 18+ to check in).
Explore how 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·