
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge
Best for guests who want a nature-led, active Brooklyn base with rooftop swimming and a strong wellness program.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is a five-star, nature-forward waterfront hotel in Brooklyn Heights with a seasonal rooftop pool and a wellness-forward program — read this if you want a sustainably minded stay with skyline and park views. The St. Regis New York is a classic Fifth Avenue grand luxury hotel in Midtown Manhattan, best for travelers who want traditional, Butler-service–style luxury steps from MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
Updated

Best for guests who want a nature-led, active Brooklyn base with rooftop swimming and a strong wellness program.

Best for travelers looking for traditional Fifth Avenue luxury, Butler service, and a central Midtown location near major Manhattan sights.
When 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge wins: pick it if you want waterfront Brooklyn views, a heated seasonal rooftop pool, a notable spa program (Bamford Wellness Spa), locally sourced restaurants, and nature-forward design. It’s a better choice for guests prioritizing outdoor access to Brooklyn Bridge Park and a more contemporary, wellness-oriented stay.
When The St. Regis New York wins: choose the St. Regis for old-school Fifth Avenue luxury, extensive Butler-service room types, proximity to Rockefeller Center/MoMA/5th Avenue shopping, and classic grand-hotel service and meeting/ballroom facilities in Midtown Manhattan.
Bottom line: Both are five-star options with very different personalities — 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for modern, wellness and waterfront-focused stays in Brooklyn; The St. Regis New York for traditional, centrally located Midtown luxury and Butler service.
| Category | 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge | The St. Regis New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, nature-led design with Brooklyn Park views | Classic grand Fifth Avenue luxury; formal service |
| Location | Brooklyn Heights waterfront, adjacent to Brooklyn Bridge Park and NYC Ferry | Midtown Manhattan on Fifth Avenue, steps from Rockefeller Center and MoMA |
| Size | About 194–195 rooms | 238 air-conditioned guestrooms |
| Age / style | Modern conversion with contemporary sustainable design | Traditional early‑20th-century grand hotel style |
| Pools / signature amenity | Heated seasonal rooftop pool (guest-only; open daily 7am–7pm, weather permitting) | No pool on file |
| Restaurants & bars | Barbuto Brooklyn, Neighbors Café, Harriet’s Rooftop, Harriet’s Lounge | 2 restaurants and 1 bar/lounge; in-room dining (limited hours) |
| Spa & wellness | Bamford Wellness Spa (5,000 sq ft, nine treatment rooms) + 24-hour Field House gym | Not published |
| Meeting & event spaces | Multiple venues incl. Meadow Rue (5,545 sq ft), rooftop and terraces; flexible spaces up to ~11,000 sq ft total | Conference space ~3,944 sq ft, 13 meeting rooms, ballroom and reception facilities |
| Sustainability highlights | Nature-forward programming; locally sourced food (80%+), LED lighting, amenity fee supports house car and wellness | Reusable tableware only, extensive recycling, locally sourced food on site (80% or more) and other sustainability measures |
| Accessibility & family policy | All-ages property; guests must be 18+ to check in; amenity fee applies | Welcomes guests of all sexual orientations and gender identities; check-in min age 21; adults allowed |
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge sits on Pier 1 at Brooklyn Bridge Park with close walking access to DUMBO and the Brooklyn Bridge.
Choose 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for waterfront access, park walks, and easy ferry/subway links to Manhattan.
The St. Regis New York is on Two East 55th St, steps from 5th Avenue, Rockefeller Center, and MoMA.
Pick The St. Regis for classic Midtown convenience and immediate access to Manhattan’s major attractions.
Rooms at 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge emphasize sustainable materials, East River or Manhattan skyline views and contemporary finishes.
Rooms are modern and eco-conscious, with options for suites and skyline-facing rooms.
The St. Regis offers a wide range of Butler-service room types and classic suite layouts.
The St. Regis is for travelers who value Butler service and traditional, spacious suite options in Midtown.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge focuses on local, seasonal menus and skyline-facing bars.
Good choice for diners who want locally sourced menus and rooftop cocktails with skyline or bridge views.
The St. Regis lists two restaurants and a bar/lounge, plus limited-hours room service.
Expect formal dining options and traditional hotel food-and-beverage service in a Fifth Avenue setting.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge’s rooftop pool and wellness programming are central to the property’s appeal.
If a rooftop swim and outdoorsy hotel programming matter, 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge delivers.
The St. Regis emphasizes Butler service and Midtown grand-hotel amenities rather than a pool.
The St. Regis trades a pool for traditional luxury services and Butler-style attention in Midtown.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge centers wellness in a large Bamford Wellness Spa plus a 24-hour gym and rooftop wellness activities.
Choose 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge if you want a serious spa program combined with lively rooftop nightlife.
The St. Regis provides traditional luxury services and a 24-hour fitness center; spa details are not published in the supplied listing.
St. Regis offers classic hotel facilities and service; if an on-site spa is a must, confirm specific treatments and availability with the hotel.

1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge — heated seasonal rooftop pool with Manhattan skyline and Brooklyn Bridge views.

The St. Regis New York — Butler-service room types and a traditional Midtown address near Rockefeller Center and MoMA.

1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge — Bamford Wellness Spa with nine treatment rooms and signature holistic therapies.

The St. Regis New York — extensive meeting rooms and ballroom facilities with dedicated event spaces.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge has a heated seasonal rooftop pool (guest-only); The St. Regis New York does not list a pool in the supplier information.
The St. Regis New York — it’s on Fifth Avenue within a short walk of Rockefeller Center, MoMA, and St. Patrick’s Cathedral.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge — it highlights the Bamford Wellness Spa, 24-hour fitness center, and wellness programming included with the amenity fee.
Both properties accept guests of all ages, though 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge requires the main guest to be at least 18 to check in; the St. Regis listing shows a minimum check-in age of 21.
Explore how 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·