
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge
Best for guests who want Brooklyn Bridge Park, a rooftop swim, and a wellness-forward stay.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is a five-star, nature-forward waterfront hotel in Brooklyn Heights with a seasonal heated rooftop pool and strong wellness focus; read this if you want easy park and skyline access and a sustainability-minded stay. The New York EDITION is a five-star, stylish Flatiron lifestyle hotel near Madison Square Park; read this if you prefer a central Manhattan address and a fashion-forward, design-led hotel experience.
Updated · about 2.5 km apart

Best for guests who want Brooklyn Bridge Park, a rooftop swim, and a wellness-forward stay.

Best for travelers who want a fashionable Manhattan base steps from Madison Square Park and Flatiron.
When 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge wins: pick 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge if you prioritize waterfront views, direct access to Brooklyn Bridge Park, an on-site heated rooftop pool (seasonal), and a large spa program.
When The New York EDITION wins: choose The New York EDITION if you want a central Flatiron/ Madison Square Park location, a smaller, fashion-lifestyle hotel footprint with a noted signature restaurant and bars, and short walks to midtown destinations.
Bottom line: both are five-star hotels with strong design and service; pick 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for a nature-led, wellness and waterfront stay in Brooklyn, and The New York EDITION for a Manhattan lifestyle address and easy access to Flatiron and Madison Square Park.
| Category | 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge | The New York EDITION |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Nature-led, sustainability-minded waterfront luxury with wellness focus | Stylish Flatiron luxury lifestyle hotel with designer-led public spaces |
| Location | Brooklyn Heights, adjacent to Brooklyn Bridge Park and Pier 1 | Flatiron / Madison Square Park neighborhood (5 Madison Avenue, Manhattan) |
| Size (rooms) | 194–195 guest rooms | 271 rooms |
| Ages / policy | All-ages property; primary guest must be 18+ to check in | |
| Pools | Heated seasonal rooftop pool (guest-only; 7am–7pm when open) | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues incl. Barbuto Brooklyn, Neighbors Café, Harriet’s Rooftop and Harriet’s Lounge | The Clocktower restaurant, 2 bars/lounges, 24-hour room service |
| Spa & fitness | Bamford Wellness Spa (9 treatment rooms) and 24-hour Field House fitness center | Spa treatment room(s) and 24-hour fitness facilities listed |
| Known for | Waterfront location, sustainability features, wellness programming and rooftop pool | Madison Square Park / Flatiron location and EDITION lifestyle design |
| Meetings & events | Extensive event spaces including Meadow Rue ballroom (5,545 sq ft) and many flexible venues | Conference space ~2,100 sq ft and 5 meeting rooms |
| Transport links | DUMBO ferry and High Street–Brooklyn Bridge subway nearby; easy ferry to Manhattan | Central Manhattan walkable to Flatiron, close to multiple subway lines |
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge sits on Pier 1 of Brooklyn Bridge Park with direct park and East River access.
Choose 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for a quieter, waterfront Brooklyn base and park access.
The New York EDITION is located at 5 Madison Avenue, immediately adjacent to Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building.
Pick The New York EDITION for a central Manhattan location and short walks to Flatiron and midtown destinations.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge has roughly 194–195 rooms and suites with nature-inspired design and city/water views.
Rooms focus on eco-minded materials and water/skyline views — good for guests who value sustainability.
The New York EDITION offers 271 air-conditioned rooms with Smart TVs and minibars.
Edition rooms combine modern tech and classic hotel comforts in a Manhattan setting.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge has several on-site dining options, including Barbuto Brooklyn (chef-driven), a café and rooftop bars.
Choose 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for varied venues with local, seasonal sourcing and rooftop cocktails.
The New York EDITION features The Clocktower restaurant, two bars/lounges and 24-hour room service.
The New York EDITION offers a compact but well-regarded restaurant and bar program in the Flatiron neighborhood.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge’s signature amenity is a heated seasonal rooftop pool and pool deck with skyline views.
If a rooftop swim and poolside experience matter, 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is the clear choice.
The New York EDITION highlights lifestyle public spaces and bars rather than a noted rooftop pool.
The EDITION emphasizes design-led public spaces and bars; pool availability is not published.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge emphasizes wellness with a full Bamford spa and 24-hour fitness center.
Expect a robust wellness program plus lively rooftop nightlife at 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge.
The New York EDITION lists spa treatment rooms and 24-hour fitness facilities, aligning with a lifestyle hotel model.
The EDITION covers wellness essentials and provides in-hotel evening bars; details on spa size and treatments are more limited in the supplier listing.

1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge — heated seasonal rooftop pool with direct skyline and Brooklyn Bridge views.

The New York EDITION — steps from Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building.

1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge — Bamford Wellness Spa with nine treatment rooms and a wide menu of treatments.

The New York EDITION — designer lifestyle hotel with The Clocktower restaurant and two bars/lounges in a walkable Manhattan neighborhood.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is a short walk (about 5 minutes) from the Brooklyn Bridge; The New York EDITION is across the river in Manhattan.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge has a heated seasonal rooftop pool for registered guests; a pool is not published for The New York EDITION.
The New York EDITION is right by Madison Square Park and the Flatiron Building, making it the better walking base for that neighborhood.
Yes. 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge has the Bamford Wellness Spa (nine treatment rooms) and a 24-hour Field House; The New York EDITION lists spa treatment room(s) and 24-hour fitness facilities.
Explore how 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·