
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge
Best for skyline views, direct access to Brooklyn Bridge Park, and a seasonal rooftop pool.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is a five-star, nature-forward waterfront hotel in Brooklyn Heights with a seasonal rooftop pool and local-food restaurants; read this if you want a contemporary, sustainability-minded Brooklyn base with skyline views. Waldorf Astoria New York is a legendary, restored Midtown luxury hotel with classic Art Deco style and full-service spa; read this if you want a historic, centrally located Manhattan option and classic luxury service.
Updated · about 4.5 km apart

Best for skyline views, direct access to Brooklyn Bridge Park, and a seasonal rooftop pool.

Best for a classic Midtown address, historic Art Deco atmosphere, and large full-service luxury facilities.
When 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge wins: choose 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge if you want waterfront access to Brooklyn Bridge Park, a seasonal heated rooftop pool, locally focused dining, and a sustainability-minded, contemporary hotel experience outside Manhattan’s Midtown crowds.
When Waldorf Astoria New York wins: choose the Waldorf if you want to be in Midtown near Fifth Avenue, Rockefeller Center, and Grand Central, and if a large, traditional full-service luxury hotel with multiple restaurants, bars, meeting spaces, and a full spa matters to you.
Bottom line: pick 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for a modern, neighborhood-focused stay with outdoor pool access and Brooklyn views; pick Waldorf Astoria New York for iconic Midtown location and historic luxury amenities.
| Category | 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge | Waldorf Astoria New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Contemporary, nature-led design; Brooklyn neighborhood focus | Historic Art Deco landmark; Midtown luxury |
| Location | Waterfront at Pier 1, Brooklyn Bridge Park; near DUMBO and Brooklyn Bridge | Midtown Manhattan on Park Avenue; steps from 5th Avenue and Rockefeller Center |
| Size (rooms) | About 194–195 guest rooms and suites | 375 guestrooms |
| Age / building | Modern conversion/newer property (recently opened in this location) | Legendary, restored Midtown hotel with historic Art Deco heritage |
| Pools | Heated seasonal rooftop pool (open daily 7am–7pm when weather permits) reserved for guests | Not published |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site options: Barbuto Brooklyn, Neighbors Café, Harriet’s Rooftop, Harriet’s Lounge, in-room dining | Three restaurants and two bars/lounges listed; 24-hour room service available |
| Spa & fitness | Bamford Wellness Spa (5,000 sq ft, nine treatment rooms) plus 24-hour Field House fitness center with Peloton bikes | Full-service spa and 24-hour health club listed |
| Known for | Brooklyn Bridge Park access, sustainability features, rooftop pool and skyline views | Historic name and Midtown address near Fifth Avenue and Grand Central |
| Event spaces | Extensive waterfront event and ballroom spaces (Meadow Rue, Blue Wood Aster, Harriet's venues, Screening Room) | Conference center and meeting rooms / ballroom facilities |
| Pet policy | Pet-friendly, pet beds and bowls provided, no refundable pet deposit listed | Food and water bowls listed; supplier listing includes 'Food and water bowls' but full pet policy not detailed |
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge sits at Pier 1 on Brooklyn Bridge Park with immediate waterfront and Brooklyn Bridge views.
Pick this if you want Brooklyn’s waterfront and easy access to skyline promenades and ferries.
Waldorf Astoria New York is centrally located on Park Avenue in Midtown, within easy walking distance of Fifth Avenue and Rockefeller Center.
Pick this if you want to be in the middle of Midtown Manhattan near major attractions and transport hubs.
Rooms at 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge emphasize sustainability, local materials, and skyline or park views.
Choose 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for contemporary rooms with a nature-forward design and strong views of the East River and Manhattan skyline.
Waldorf Astoria New York has a wide range of classic guest rooms and multiple junior and one-bedroom suites.
Choose Waldorf Astoria for a larger selection of traditional luxury rooms and suites in a landmark Midtown building.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge emphasizes locally sourced menus and neighborhood chefs.
Pick 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for locally sourced menus, a chef-driven signature restaurant, and rooftop cocktail options with views.
Waldorf Astoria offers multiple restaurants and bars with 24-hour room service.
Pick Waldorf Astoria if you want the convenience and variety of in-house restaurants and classic hotel dining in Midtown.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge’s notable amenity is its heated seasonal rooftop pool overlooking the East River and Manhattan skyline.
If a rooftop pool and outdoor skyline views matter, 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is the clear choice.
Waldorf Astoria’s supplier listing highlights full-service hotel facilities but does not publish a pool.
Waldorf is focused on classic luxury services and a full spa rather than a rooftop-pool experience (pool details not published).
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge offers a sizeable wellness program and active nightlife with rooftop bars.
Book 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge for comprehensive spa services plus rooftop nightspots with skyline views.
Waldorf Astoria includes a full-service spa and 24-hour health club as part of its classic luxury offer.
Choose Waldorf Astoria for a traditional hotel spa and easy access to Midtown nightlife and theaters.

Heated seasonal rooftop pool with Manhattan views and guest-only access.

Central Park/5th Avenue/Midtown attractions and Grand Central are a short walk away.

Barbuto Brooklyn from chef Jonathan Waxman plus locally sourced café and rooftop outlets.

A legendary, restored Midtown hotel with extensive meeting and banquet facilities and classic service.
1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge has a heated seasonal rooftop pool (guest-only). A pool is not published in the Waldorf Astoria New York supplier listing provided.
Waldorf Astoria New York is in Midtown near Fifth Avenue, Rockefeller Center, and Grand Central; 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge is waterfront in Brooklyn and better for Brooklyn Bridge Park and DUMBO.
Yes. 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge lists the Bamford Wellness Spa; Waldorf Astoria New York’s supplier listing notes full spa services on site.
Both have extensive event facilities: 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge has multiple waterfront ballrooms and meeting rooms, while Waldorf Astoria lists a conference center and meeting rooms in its supplier listing.
No. Both properties accept guests of all ages per the available information; 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge requires the primary booker to be at least 18.
Explore how 1 Hotel Brooklyn Bridge stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·